Last Updated: Nov 22, 2022
Quick Links: Table of Contents
- Are Collies Aggressive Towards Strangers?
- Are Collies Aggressive Towards their Owners?
- Are Collies Aggressive Towards other Dogs?
- Are Collies Afraid of Strangers?
- Are Collies Afraid of Other Dogs?
- Do Collies Have Non-Social Fears?
- Do Collies Get Along Well With Other Dogs?
- Are Collies Easy to Train?
- Do Collies Get Along Well with Cats? Do They Get Along Well with Other Pets?
- Do Collies Like Attention? Are they Clingy or Aloof?
- Do Collies have Separation Anxiety? Do They Like to be Left Alone?
- Are Collies Touch Sensitive? Do They Like to be Groomed?
- Are Collies Hyper? Are they Highly Excitable?
- Are Collies Playful? What is the Energy Level of Collies
- Conclusion on Collie Temperament
Introduction to the Temperament of the Collie
The are many descriptions of the temperament of the Collie out there. However, most of these descriptions are difficult to verify or prove. They are based on mere speculations.
In this article, we will provide a factual description of the temperament of the Collie based on solid scientific research. This will give you a better understanding of what you can expect from the Collie breed.
We obtained our description of the temperament of Collie by analyzing raw scientific data from The Canine Behavioral Assessment & Research Questionnaire (C-BARQ) database.
The C-BARQ dog temperament standard was developed by researchers from the University of Pennsylvania. It is considered the gold standard for measuring the behavior of dogs.
Over the years, the C-BARQ study has collected data on the temperament of thousands of dogs of different breeds including the Collie.
The C-BARQ study obtains its data by asking dog owners to score the behavior of their dogs on different behavior patterns.
The idea behind the C-BARQ study is that if it collects thousands of scores from thousands of dog owners on different aspects of dog behavior, a clear pattern will emerge on the temperament of different dog breeds.
The C-BARQ questionnaire measures 14 behavior aspects of dogs:
- Aggression towards stranger
- Aggression towards its owner
- Aggression towards other dogs
- How well they get along with other dogs
- Fear of strangers
- Fear of new things (new objects, unfamiliar loud sounds, etc)
- Fear of other dogs
- Separation anxiety
- Clinginess
- Trainability/ Stubbornness
- Prey drive
- Excitability
- Touch sensitivity
- Energy level
In this article, we will discuss the score of the Collie for each of these 14 characteristics. This will let you know the real temperament of the Collie.
The summary table below shows the score of the Collie for the different behavioral characteristics.
High percentage scores close to 100 are bad. Low percentage scores close to 0 are good.
| Behavior | Score |
|---|---|
| Owner Directed Aggression | 6.5 percent |
| Attachment Attention Seeking | 41.1 percent |
| Energy Level | 38.7 percent |
| Dog Rivalry | 26.0 percent |
| Prey Drive | 23.9 percent |
| Stranger Directed Aggression | 19.3 percent |
| Nonsocial Fear | 17.7 percent |
| Touch Sensitivity | 17.4 percent |
| Separation Related Behavior | 16.5 percent |
| Dog Directed Aggression | 16.1 percent |
| Excitability | 14.0 percent |
| Stubbornness | 13.6 percent |
| Stranger Directed Fear | 13.0 percent |
| Dog Directed Fear | 11.4 percent |
Note that with proper training, you can better your Collie`s temperament. To learn how to properly train your Collie, I highly recommend that you go through Dr. Ian Dunbar`s online dog training classes, which you can find here.
I learned most of the things that I know about training dogs by reading Dr. Dunbar`s books and watching his training videos. Dr. Dunbar`s dog training methods are for people expecting to own a puppy soon, new dog owners, and experienced dog owners.
Another helpful online dog training class that I recommend is this one. The class will teach you how to properly train your Collie.
See also our complete ranking of dog breeds from the `best` to the `worst` based on temperament.
Are Collies Aggressive Towards Strangers?
Dog breeds that are aggressive to strangers show hostile responses to strangers approaching or invading the dog`s or the dog owner`s personal space, territory, or home range.
Stranger-aggressive dog breeds are quick to show aggression to unfamiliar people.
Typical signs of moderate aggression in dogs include barking, growling, and baring of teeth. More serious display of aggression generally includes snapping, lunging, biting, or attempting to bite.
Collies are not aggressive towards strangers.
This is because the Collie ranks very low for aggression towards strangers.
The Collie ranks number 101 out of 124 dog breeds for aggression towards strangers.
This information is based on what 243 Collie owners reported on the temperament of their Collie in a research survey.
Based on our further analysis of the survey, we found that the Collie has a stranger-directed-aggression score of 19.3 %.
Other dog breeds that are not aggressive towards strangers just like the Collie are listed in the table below
| Stranger-Directed-Aggression Rank | Breed | Stranger-Directed-Aggression Score |
|---|---|---|
| 98 | Border Terrier | 20.5 % |
| 99 | Staffordshire Bull Terrier | 20.1 % |
| 100 | Eurasier | 20.0 % |
| 101 | Collie | 19.3 % |
| 102 | Bernese Mountain Dog | 18.8 % |
| 103 | Portuguese Water Dog | 18.7 % |
| 104 | Basset Hound | 17.1 % |
The dog breeds that are most aggressive towards strangers are the:
The dog breeds that are least aggressive towards strangers are the:
Usually, small dog breeds display aggression not because they are mean but because they are afraid and feel insecure due to their small size.
Are Collies Aggressive Towards their Owners?
Due to human effort over the course of many centuries, the dog has become a very domestic animal. Dogs have learned to live well with humans. As a result, dogs respect and love their owners. Nevertheless, some dog breeds are less respectful to their owners than some other dog breeds.
Owner-aggressive dog breeds show threatening or hostile responses to their owner or other members of the household when challenged, manhandled, stared at, stepped over, or when approached while in possession of food, objects, or toys.
A dog that is owner-aggressive shows its aggression by barking, growling, and baring of teeth. In extreme cases, these dogs can snap, lunge, bite, or attempt to bite their owners.
Collies are not aggressive towards their owners.
This is because the Collie ranks very low for aggression towards its owner.
The Collie ranks number 108 out of 124 dog breeds for aggression towards their owners.
This information is based on what 243 Collie owners reported on the temperament of their Collie in a research survey.
Based on our further analysis of the survey, we found that the Collie has an owner-directed-aggression score of 6.5 %.
Other dog breeds that are not owner-aggressive just like the Collie are listed in the table below
| Owner-Directed-Aggression Rank | Breed | Owner-Directed-Aggression Score |
|---|---|---|
| 105 | Brittany | 6.9 % |
| 106 | Doberman Pinscher | 6.7 % |
| 107 | Pit Bull | 6.6 % |
| 108 | Collie | 6.5 % |
| 109 | Nova Scotia Duck Tolling Retriever | 6.4 % |
| 110 | Poodle (Standard) | 6.4 % |
| 111 | Great Dane | 6.1 % |
The dog breeds that show the most aggression towards their owners are the:
The dog breeds that are least aggressive towards their owners are the:
Usually, small dog breeds display aggression not because they are mean but because they are afraid and feel insecure due to their small size.
Are Collies Aggressive Towards other Dogs?
Dogs that are aggressive towards other dogs will direct aggressive threats or actions toward unknown or unfamiliar dogs.
A dog-aggressive dog will threaten or show hostile responses when approached by unfamiliar dogs
A dog that is dog-aggressive shows its aggression by barking, growling, and baring of teeth. In extreme cases, these dogs can snap, lunge, bite, or attempt to bite other dogs.
Collies are not aggressive towards other dogs.
This is because the Collie ranks very low for aggression towards other dogs.
The Collie ranks number 117 out of 124 dog breeds for aggression towards other dogs.
This information is based on what 243 Collie owners reported on the temperament of their Collie in a research survey.
Based on our further analysis of the survey, we found that the Collie has a dog-directed aggression score of 16.1 %.
Other dog breeds that are not dog-aggressive just like the Collie are listed in the table below
| Dog-Directed-Aggression Rank | Breed | Dog-Directed-Aggression Score |
|---|---|---|
| 114 | Whippet | 19.3 % |
| 115 | Nova Scotia Duck Tolling Retriever | 19.3 % |
| 116 | Greyhound | 18.0 % |
| 117 | Collie | 16.1 % |
| 118 | Bearded Collie | 15.2 % |
| 119 | Eurasier | 13.2 % |
| 120 | Keeshond | 13.2 % |
The dog breeds that show the most aggression towards other dogs are the:
The dog breeds that are least aggressive towards other dogs are the:
Usually, small dog breeds display aggression not because they are mean but because they are afraid and feel insecure due to their small size.
Are Collies Afraid of Strangers?
Some dogs breeds tend to be fearful of strangers.
Dogs that are fearful of strangers will avoid strangers. These dogs will crouch, cringe, or tremble when approached by strangers.
Extreme fear in dogs is characterized by serious attempts to escape or hide from the feared stranger.
Collies are not fearful of strangers.
This is because the Collie ranks very low for fear of strangers.
The Collie ranks number 99 out of 124 dog breeds for fear of strangers.
This information is based on what 243 Collie owners reported on the temperament of their Collie in a research survey.
Based on our further analysis of the survey, we found that the Collie has a stranger-directed-fear score of 13.0 %.
Other dog breeds that are not stranger-fearful just like the Collie are listed in the table below
| Stranger-Directed-Fear Rank | Breed | Stranger-Directed-Fear Score |
|---|---|---|
| 96 | Kuvasz | 14.5 % |
| 97 | Bull Terrier | 14.0 % |
| 98 | Samoyed | 13.6 % |
| 99 | Collie | 13.0 % |
| 100 | Labrador Retriever | 12.8 % |
| 101 | Irish Setter | 11.7 % |
| 102 | Pointer | 11.5 % |
The dog breeds that show the most fear of strangers are the:
The dog breeds that are least fearful of strangers are the:
Are Collies Afraid of Other Dogs?
Some dogs breeds tend to show fear when an unfamiliar dog approaches them.
A dog that is fearful of other dogs will try to avoid meeting other dogs.
Collies are not fearful of other dogs.
This is because the Collie ranks very low for fear of other dogs.
The Collie ranks number 117 out of 124 dog breeds for fear of other dogs.
This information is based on what 243 Collie owners reported on the temperament of their Collie in a research survey.
Based on our further analysis of the survey, we found that the Collie has a dog-directed-fear score of 11.4 %.
Other dog breeds that are not other-dog-fearful just like the Collie are listed in the table below
| Dog-Directed-Fear Rank | Breed | Dog-Directed-Fear Score |
|---|---|---|
| 114 | Nova Scotia Duck Tolling Retriever | 12.9 % |
| 115 | Anatolian Shepherd | 12.8 % |
| 116 | Dingo | 12.2 % |
| 117 | Collie | 11.4 % |
| 118 | Airedale Terrier | 9.7 % |
| 119 | Pointer | 9.7 % |
| 120 | Kuvasz | 8.4 % |
The dog breeds that are most fearful of other dogs are the:
The dog breeds that are least fearful of other dogs are the:
Do Collies Have Non-Social Fears?
Dogs that are fearful of sudden or loud noises, traffic, and unfamiliar objects and situations are said to exhibit nonsocial fear.
Collies are not fearful of unfamiliar sounds, situations, and objects.
This is because the Collie ranks very low for non-social fear.
The Collie ranks number 98 out of 124 dog breeds for being fearful of unfamiliar things and situations.
This information is based on what 243 Collie owners reported on the temperament of their Collie in a research survey.
Based on our further analysis of the survey, we found that the Collie has a nonsocial-fear score of 17.7 %.
Other dog breeds that are not nonsocial-fearful just like the Collie are listed in the table below
| Nonsocial-Fear Rank | Breed | Nonsocial-Fear Score |
|---|---|---|
| 95 | Weimaraner | 18.4 % |
| 96 | Chesapeake Bay Retriever | 18.3 % |
| 97 | Pointer | 17.9 % |
| 98 | Collie | 17.7 % |
| 99 | Irish Water Spaniel | 17.6 % |
| 100 | Basset Hound | 17.5 % |
| 101 | Airedale Terrier | 17.2 % |
The dog breeds that are most fearful of unfamiliar situations and objects are the:
The dog breeds that are least fearful of unfamiliar situations and objects are the:
Do Collies Get Along Well With Other Dogs?
Some dog breeds display high dog rivalry. These dog breeds will threaten or act hostile to other familiar dogs in the same household.
These dog breeds will compete with other dogs. Also, these dog breeds do not get along well with other dogs.
Collies are not competitive when dealing with other dogs.
This is because the Collie ranks very low on dog rivalry.
The Collie ranks number 97 out of 124 dog breeds for displaying dog rivalry when dealing with familiar dogs.
This information is based on what 243 Collie owners reported on the temperament of their Collie in a research survey.
Based on our further analysis of the survey, we found that the Collie has a dog-rivalry score of 26.0 %.
Other dog breeds that are not competition-driven just like the Collie are listed in the table below
| Dog-Rivalry Rank | Breed | Dog-Rivalry Score |
|---|---|---|
| 94 | Black and Tan Coonhound | 27.4 % |
| 95 | German Wirehaired Pointer | 27.3 % |
| 96 | Whippet | 26.3 % |
| 97 | Collie | 26.0 % |
| 98 | German Shorthaired Pointer | 25.4 % |
| 99 | Rhodesian Ridgeback | 25.0 % |
| 100 | Mastiff (English) | 24.9 % |
The dog breeds that do not get along well with other dogs are the:
The dog breeds that get along well with other dogs are the:
See our complete ranking of dog breeds based on how well they get along with other dog breeds.
Are Collies Easy to Train?
Dogs have high trainability have the willingness to listen to their owner. These dogs are not stubborn. These dogs obey simple commands, and they learn very quickly.
Highly trainable dogs excel at fetching objects. They also respond positively to correction and ignore distraction.
Collies are very much easy to train.
This is because the Collie ranks very high for trainability.
The Collie ranks number 15 out of 124 dog breeds for easiness to train.
This information is based on what 243 Collie owners reported on the trainability of their Collie in a research survey.
Based on our further analysis of the survey, we found that the Collie has a trainability score of 86.4 %.
Other dog breeds that are very much easy to train just like the Collie are listed in the table below
| Trainability Rank | Breed | Trainability Score |
|---|---|---|
| 12 | Poodle (Standard) | 88.6 % |
| 13 | English Springer Spaniel | 88.2 % |
| 14 | German Wirehaired Pointer | 88.1 % |
| 15 | Collie | 86.4 % |
| 16 | German Shepherd | 86.0 % |
| 17 | Golden Retriever | 85.8 % |
| 18 | Vizsla | 85.2 % |
The dog breeds that are most easy to train are the:
The dog breeds that are difficult to train are the:
Learn more about how intelligent the Collie is and how the intelligence of the Collie affects its trainability in this article on how smart the Collie is.
Do Collies Get Along Well with Cats? Do They Get Along Well with Other Pets?
Dog breeds that have high chase-drive will run after (chase) cats, birds, and/or other small animals, given the opportunity.
Collies are not into chasing after other smaller pets like cats, squirrels, chickens, and birds.
This is because the Collie ranks very low for small-pet-chasing.
The Collie ranks number 114 out of 124 dog breeds for chasing after smaller pets.
This information is based on what 243 Collie owners reported on the temperament of their Collie in a research survey.
Based on our further analysis of the survey, we found that the Collie has a chasing score of 23.9 %.
Other dog breeds that are not into chasing after smaller pets just like the Collie are listed in the table below
| Chasing Rank | Breed | Chasing Score |
|---|---|---|
| 111 | Chinese Crested | 26.2 % |
| 112 | French Bulldog | 25.1 % |
| 113 | English Bulldog | 24.0 % |
| 114 | Collie | 23.9 % |
| 115 | Samoyed | 19.8 % |
| 116 | Anatolian Shepherd | 19.8 % |
| 117 | Black and Tan Coonhound | 19.2 % |
The dog breeds that like chasing after cats and other smaller pets are the:
The dog breeds that will not chase after cats and other smaller pets are the:
See our complete ranking of dog breeds based on their prey drive.
Do Collies Like Attention? Are they Clingy or Aloof?
Some dog breeds like to stay close to their owners all the time. These dogs like attention, and they like to receive the affection of their owners.
These dogs get jealous when their owners give attention to other dogs or other people instead of them.
Dogs with these traits are described as attachment/attention-seeking.
Collies are a little bit attachment/attention-seeking.
This is because the Collie ranks low for attachment/attention-seeking behavior.
The Collie ranks number 88 out of 124 dog breeds for attachment/attention-seeking behavior.
This information is based on what 243 Collie owners reported on the temperament of their Collie in a research survey.
Based on our further analysis of the survey, we found that the Collie has an attachment/attention-seeking score of 41.1 %.
Other dog breeds that are a little bit attachment/attention-seeking just like the Collie are listed in the table below
| Attachment-Attention-Seeking Rank | Breed | Attachment-Attention-Seeking Score |
|---|---|---|
| 85 | Lagotto Romagnolo | 42.2 % |
| 86 | Bouvier des Flandres | 41.8 % |
| 87 | Anatolian Shepherd | 41.2 % |
| 88 | Collie | 41.1 % |
| 89 | Italian Greyhound | 40.0 % |
| 90 | Keeshond | 39.7 % |
| 91 | German Shorthaired Pointer | 38.6 % |
The dog breeds that are always seeking the attention of their owners are the:
The dog breeds that are aloof are the:
See our complete ranking of dog breeds based on their clinginess.
Do Collies have Separation Anxiety? Do They Like to be Left Alone?
Dog breeds that have separation anxiety do not like to be left alone.
These dog breeds tend to bark and destroy things when separated from their owners.
They become restless or lose their appetite when left alone.
Collies are not prone to developing separation anxiety.
This is because the Collie ranks very low for separation anxiety relative to other dog breeds.
The Collie ranks number 111 out of 124 dog breeds for separation anxiety.
This information is based on what 243 Collie owners reported on the temperament of their Collie in a research survey.
Based on our further analysis of the survey, we found that the Collie has a separation anxiety score of 16.5 %.
Other dog breeds that are not prone to develop separation anxiety just like the Collie are listed in the table below
| Separation-Related-Behavior Rank | Breed | Separation-Related-Behavior Score |
|---|---|---|
| 108 | Rottweiler | 17.3 % |
| 109 | English Setter | 16.6 % |
| 110 | Irish Wolfhound | 16.6 % |
| 111 | Collie | 16.5 % |
| 112 | Golden Retriever | 16.0 % |
| 113 | Schipperke | 15.8 % |
| 114 | Nova Scotia Duck Tolling Retriever | 15.6 % |
The dog breeds that are most prone to develop separation anxiety are listed below. These dog breeds do not like to be left alone. These dog breeds are the:
- Treeing Walker Coonhound
- Fox Terrier (Smooth)
- Chinese Crested
- Miniature Pinscher
- Australian Silky Terrier
The dog breeds that are least prone to develop separation anxiety are the:
See our complete ranking of dog breeds based on their tendency to develop separation anxiety.
Are Collies Touch Sensitive? Do They Like to be Groomed?
Dogs that are touch-sensitive are fearful of `painful` procedures such as bathing, grooming, nail clipping, and veterinary examinations.
These dogs do not like going through these `painful` procedures, and they will react to show they do not like the procedure.
Collies are not touch-sensitive.
This is because the Collie ranks very low for touch sensitivity.
The Collie ranks number 105 out of 124 dog breeds for touch sensitivity.
This information is based on what 243 Collie owners reported on the temperament of their Collie in a research survey.
Based on our further analysis of the survey, we found that the Collie has a touch-sensitivity score of 17.4 %.
Other dog breeds that are not touch-sensitive just like the Collie are listed in the table below
| Touch-Sensitivity Rank | Breed | Touch-Sensitivity Score |
|---|---|---|
| 102 | Belgian Sheepdog | 19.0 % |
| 103 | Bouvier des Flandres | 18.9 % |
| 104 | Boston Terrier | 18.5 % |
| 105 | Collie | 17.4 % |
| 106 | Cavalier King Charles Spaniel | 17.0 % |
| 107 | Rottweiler | 16.8 % |
| 108 | Irish Wolfhound | 16.6 % |
The dog breeds that are most touch-sensitive are the:
The dog breeds that are least touch-sensitive are the:
See our complete ranking of dog breeds based on their sensitivity to touch.
Are Collies Hyper? Are they Highly Excitable?
Excitable dog or hyper dog breeds display strong reactions to potentially exciting or arousing events, such as:
- going for walks
- car trips
- sound of the doorbell
- arrival of visitors, and
- the owner arriving home
Highly excitable dog breeds have difficulty settling down after arousal.
Collies are not hyper (excitable).
This is because the Collie ranks very low for excitability.
The Collie ranks number 119 out of 124 dog breeds for excitability.
This information is based on what 243 Collie owners reported on the temperament of their Collie in a research survey.
Based on our further analysis of the survey, we found that the Collie has an excitability score of 14.0 %.
Other dog breeds that are not excitable just like the Collie are listed in the table below
| Excitability Rank | Breed | Excitability Score |
|---|---|---|
| 116 | Kuvasz | 18.1 % |
| 117 | Rhodesian Ridgeback | 16.9 % |
| 118 | Eurasier | 15.0 % |
| 119 | Collie | 14.0 % |
| 120 | Anatolian Shepherd | 11.7 % |
| 121 | Italian Greyhound | 9.1 % |
| 122 | Great Pyrenees | 6.2 % |
The dog breeds that are most hyper (excitable) are the:
- Australian Silky Terrier
- Fox Terrier (Smooth)
- American Eskimo Dog
- Parson Russell Terrier
- Miniature Schnauzer
The dog breeds that are least hyper (excitable) are the:
See our complete ranking of dog breeds based on how hyper they are.
Are Collies Playful? What is the Energy Level of Collies
Energetic dog breeds are very playful dog breeds. These are the dog breeds that do not get tired easily.
Collies are not energetic.
This is because the Collie ranks very low for energy level.
The Collie ranks number 97 out of 124 dog breeds for energy level.
This information is based on what 243 Collie owners reported on the temperament of their Collie in a research survey.
Based on our further analysis of the survey, we found that the Collie has an energy-level score of 38.7 %.
Other dog breeds that are not energetic just like the Collie are listed in the table below
| Energy-Level Rank | Breed | Energy-Level Score |
|---|---|---|
| 94 | Bernese Mountain Dog | 42.1 % |
| 95 | Borzoi | 42.0 % |
| 96 | Bullmastiff | 40.1 % |
| 97 | Collie | 38.7 % |
| 98 | Keeshond | 37.4 % |
| 99 | English Setter | 37.0 % |
| 100 | Great Dane | 36.5 % |
The dog breeds that are most playful and most energetic are the:
The dog breeds that are laziest are the:
See our complete ranking of dog breeds from the most energetic to the least energetic.
Conclusion on Collie Temperament
The temperament of your Collie comes from a combination of its genetics and what environment your Collie is exposed to.
You cannot change your Collie`s gene but you can change the things you expose your Collie to.
Exposing your Collie to dog training sessions early in its life can help you mold the temperament of your Collie to what you desire.
Again, with proper training, you can better your Collie`s temperament. To learn how to properly train a dog, I highly recommend Dr. Ian Dunbar`s online dog training classes, which you can find here.
I learned most of the things I know about training dogs by reading Dr. Dunbar`s books and watching his training videos. Dr. Dunbar`s dog training methods are for people expecting to own a puppy soon, new dog owners, and experienced dog owners.
Another helpful online dog training class that I recommend is this one. The class will teach you how to properly train your Collie.
If you think the Collie is the right dog breed for you, see our article on how much Collies cost and Collie puppy buying guide.
Also, see our list of reputable Collie breeders in the United States and the prices of their Collie puppies.