Ranking Dog Breeds from the Most Fearful of Other Dogs to the Least Fearful of Other Dogs

Last Updated: Nov 22, 2022

Quick Links: Table of Contents

Introduction

It used to be very difficult to reliably measure the temperament of dogs.

However, in 2015, researchers from the University of Pennsylvania developed the Canine Behavioral Assessment & Research Questionnaire (C-BARQ) tool.

Many research studies have shown that the C-BARQ tool can reliably measure the behavior of dogs.

With data from the C-BARQ tool, you can calculate how bad or good the temperament of a dog breed is.

We analyzed data from the C-BARQ database to obtain the temperament score of dog breeds for Dog Directed Fear. This allowed us to rank dogs based on Dog Directed Fear.

Note that the fact that a dog breed ranks high for bad behavior does not mean all hope is lost for the dog breed. With proper early training, you can always mold a dog`s temperament into what you want.

Also, smaller dog breeds tend to have high aggression scores. However, aggression in small dog breeds is usually born out of insecurities or fear, and less from the meanness of their hearts.

Note that Dog Directed Fear is one of the 14 temperament components that the C-BARQ test measures.

The complete 14 temperament components are:

  1. Stranger Directed Aggression
  2. Owner Directed Aggression
  3. Dog Directed Aggression
  4. Stranger Directed Fear
  5. Dog Directed Fear
  6. Nonsocial Fear
  7. Dog Rivalry
  8. Trainability
  9. Chasing
  10. Attachment Attention Seeking
  11. Separation Related Behavior
  12. Touch Sensitivity
  13. Excitability
  14. Energy Level

Below is our ranking of dog breeds based on Dog Directed Fear.

Click on the link for each breed to learn more about the complete temperament of the breed.

Click here to see our ranking of dog breeds from the ones with the overall `best` temperament to the ones with the `worst` temperament.

Dog Breeds that are Very Fearful of Other Dogs

1. Dachshund (Miniature)

Dachshund (Miniature)

Miniature Dachshund Puppy Price : $1300 to $2500

2. Fox Terrier (Toy)

Fox Terrier (Toy)

Weight of the Toy Fox Terrier : 3 to 7 pounds

Height of the Toy Fox Terrier : 8 to 11 inches at the shoulder

Lifespan of the Toy Fox Terrier : 13 to 14 years

Toy Fox Terrier Puppy Price : $1000 to $1595

See list of Reputable Toy Fox Terrier Puppy Breeders here

3. Chinese Crested

Chinese Crested

Weight of the Chinese Crested : 5 to 12 pounds

Height of the Chinese Crested : 11 to 13 inches tall at the shoulder

Lifespan of the Chinese Crested : 10 to 14 years

Chinese Crested Puppy Price : $1000 to $1800

See list of Reputable Chinese Crested Puppy Breeders here

Guide on how much food to feed the Chinese Crested

4. Chihuahua

Chihuahua

Weight of the Chihuahua : 3 to 6 pounds

Height of the Chihuahua : 6 inches to 9 inches tall at the shoulder

Lifespan of the Chihuahua : 10 to 18 years

Chihuahua Puppy Price : $900 to $2500

See list of Reputable Chihuahua Puppy Breeders here

Guide on how much food to feed the Chihuahua

5. Lhasa Apso

Lhasa Apso

Weight of the Lhasa Apso : 12 to 15 pounds

Height of the Lhasa Apso : 9 to 11 inches tall at the shoulder

Lifespan of the Lhasa Apso : 12 to 15 years

Lhasa Apso Puppy Price : $1500 to $1996

See list of Reputable Lhasa Apso Puppy Breeders here

Guide on how much food to feed the Lhasa Apso

6. Basenji

Basenji

Weight of the Basenji : 22 to 24 pounds

Height of the Basenji : 16 to 17 inches tall at the shoulder

Lifespan of the Basenji : 10 to 12 years

Basenji Puppy Price : $1450 to $1450

See list of Reputable Basenji Puppy Breeders here

Guide on how much food to feed the Basenji

7. Miniature Pinscher

Miniature Pinscher

Weight of the Miniature Pinscher : 8 to 11 pounds

Height of the Miniature Pinscher : 10 to 12 inches tall at the shoulder

Lifespan of the Miniature Pinscher : 10 to 14 years

Miniature Pinscher Puppy Price : $825 to $1500

See list of Reputable Miniature Pinscher Puppy Breeders here

Guide on how much food to feed the Miniature Pinscher

8. Maltese

Maltese

Weight of the Maltese : 6 to 9 pounds

Height of the Maltese : 8 to 10 inches tall at the shoulder

Lifespan of the Maltese : 12 to 15 years

Maltese Puppy Price : $1800 to $3000

See list of Reputable Maltese Puppy Breeders here

9. Border Terrier

Border Terrier

Weight of the Border Terrier : 11 to 15 pounds

Height of the Border Terrier : 10 to 11 inches tall at the shoulder

Lifespan of the Border Terrier : 12 to 15 years

Border Terrier Puppy Price : $800 to $1400

See list of Reputable Border Terrier Puppy Breeders here

Guide on how much food to feed the Border Terrier

10. Parson Russell Terrier

Parson Russell Terrier

Parson Russell Terrier Puppy Price : $1500 to $2000

See list of Reputable Parson Russell Terrier Puppy Breeders here

Dog Breeds that are least Fearful of other Dogs

1. Giant Schnauzer

Giant Schnauzer

Weight of the Giant Schnauzer : 55 to 80 pounds

Height of the Giant Schnauzer : 23 to 27 inches tall at the shoulder

Lifespan of the Giant Schnauzer : 10 to 12 years

Giant Schnauzer Puppy Price : $2000 to $2500

See list of Reputable Giant Schnauzer Puppy Breeders here

Guide on how much food to feed the Giant Schnauzer

2. Ibizan Hound

Ibizan Hound

Weight of the Ibizan Hound : 45 to 50 pounds

Height of the Ibizan Hound : 22 to 27 inches tall at the shoulder

Lifespan of the Ibizan Hound : 10 to 14 years

See list of Reputable Ibizan Hound Puppy Breeders here

3. Eurasier

Eurasier

Weight of the Eurasier : 40 pounds to 71 pounds

Height of the Eurasier : 19 inches to 24 inches

See list of Reputable Eurasier Puppy Breeders here

Guide on how much food to feed the Eurasier

4. Kuvasz

Kuvasz

Weight of the Kuvasz : 70 to 115 pounds

Height of the Kuvasz : 26 to 30 inches tall at the shoulder

Lifespan of the Kuvasz : 10 to 12 years

Kuvasz Puppy Price : $2000 to $2000

See list of Reputable Kuvasz Puppy Breeders here

5. Borzoi

Borzoi

Weight of the Borzoi : 55 to 105 pounds

Height of the Borzoi : 26 to 32 inches tall at the shoulder

Lifespan of the Borzoi : 10 to 12 years

Borzoi Puppy Price : $1500 to $1500

See list of Reputable Borzoi Puppy Breeders here

Guide on how much food to feed the Borzoi

6. Pointer

Pointer

Weight of the Pointer : 45 to 75 pounds

Height of the Pointer : 1 foot, 11 inches to 2 feet, 4 inches tall at the

Lifespan of the Pointer : 12 to 15 years

Pointer Puppy Price : $800 to $800

See list of Reputable Pointer Puppy Breeders here

Guide on how much food to feed the Pointer

7. Airedale Terrier

Airedale Terrier

Weight of the Airedale Terrier : 40 to 65 pounds

Height of the Airedale Terrier : 21 to 23 inches tall at the shoulder

Lifespan of the Airedale Terrier : 10 to 13 years

Airedale Terrier Puppy Price : $1000 to $1800

See list of Reputable Airedale Terrier Puppy Breeders here

8. Collie

Collie

Weight of the Collie : 50 to 70 pounds

Height of the Collie : 22 to 26 inches all at the shoulder

Lifespan of the Collie : 10 to 14 years

Collie Puppy Price : $1000 to $1800

See list of Reputable Collie Puppy Breeders here

Guide on how much food to feed the Collie

9. Dingo

Dingo

10. Anatolian Shepherd

Anatolian Shepherd

Weight of the Anatolian Shepherd Dog : 80 to 150 pounds

Height of the Anatolian Shepherd Dog : 2 feet, 3 inches to 2 feet, 5 inches tall at the s

Lifespan of the Anatolian Shepherd Dog : 11 to 13 years

Anatolian Shepherd Dog Puppy Price : $750 to $1150

See list of Reputable Anatolian Shepherd Dog Puppy Breeders here

Guide on how much food to feed the Anatolian Shepherd Dog

See below the full ranking of dog breeds based on Dog Directed Fear.

Dog-Directed-Fear Rank Breed Dog-Directed-Fear Score
1 Dachshund (Miniature) 100.0 %
2 Fox Terrier (Toy) 93.3 %
3 Chinese Crested 87.8 %
4 Chihuahua 85.8 %
5 Lhasa Apso 77.9 %
6 Basenji 76.5 %
7 Miniature Pinscher 71.9 %
8 Maltese 68.6 %
9 Border Terrier 66.9 %
10 Parson Russell Terrier 66.5 %
11 Pit Bull mix 66.2 %
12 Dachshund 62.1 %
13 Italian Greyhound 61.7 %
14 Fox Terrier (Smooth) 60.7 %
15 Tibetan Terrier 60.3 %
16 Shih Tzu 60.0 %
17 French Bulldog 59.6 %
18 Poodle (Miniature) 59.5 %
19 Treeing Walker Coonhound 59.1 %
20 American Eskimo Dog 58.8 %
21 Beagle 57.6 %
22 Poodle (Toy) 56.9 %
23 Saint Bernard 56.8 %
24 Yorkshire Terrier 56.6 %
25 English Springer Spaniel 55.0 %
26 Pekingese 55.0 %
27 Australian Kelpie 54.3 %
28 Australian Silky Terrier 53.6 %
29 Bichon Frise 53.0 %
30 Rat Terrier 51.2 %
31 Miniature Schnauzer 51.2 %
32 Lagotto Romagnolo 49.6 %
33 Cavalier King Charles Spaniel 49.5 %
34 Cocker Spaniel (English) 49.2 %
35 Dalmatian 48.8 %
36 Pomeranian 48.8 %
37 Bearded Collie 48.7 %
38 Cocker Spaniel (American) 48.7 %
39 Australian Cattle Dog 48.3 %
40 Border Collie 46.8 %
41 Afghan Hound 46.1 %
42 Bull Terrier 43.8 %
43 Weimaraner 43.6 %
44 Staffordshire Bull Terrier 43.4 %
45 Flat-Coated Retriever 43.3 %
46 West Highland White Terrier 42.9 %
47 Whippet 42.6 %
48 Havanese 42.5 %
49 Bulldog 42.0 %
50 American Bulldog 41.9 %
51 Samoyed 41.6 %
52 Shetland Sheepdog 40.8 %
53 American Pit Bull Terrier 40.2 %
54 Belgian Tervuren 40.1 %
55 Papillon 40.0 %
56 Jack Russell Terrier 39.9 %
57 Cairn Terrier 39.8 %
58 Pembroke Welsh Corgi 39.1 %
59 Australian Shepherd 39.1 %
60 Pug 38.7 %
61 Belgian Malinois 38.6 %
62 German Shepherd 37.2 %
63 Alaskan Husky 37.1 %
64 Shiba Inu 36.7 %
65 English Setter 36.0 %
66 Fox Terrier (Wire/Wire-haired) 35.7 %
67 Greyhound 34.9 %
68 Basset Hound 33.6 %
69 Cardigan Welsh Corgi 33.6 %
70 Vizsla 32.7 %
71 Standard Schnauzer 32.6 %
72 Poodle (Standard) 32.0 %
73 Norwegian Elkhound 31.8 %
74 Chinese Shar-Pei 31.6 %
75 Keeshond 31.4 %
76 Chesapeake Bay Retriever 30.4 %
77 Brittany 29.9 %
78 Golden Retriever 29.4 %
79 Labrador Retriever 27.9 %
80 Doberman Pinscher 27.7 %
81 Boxer 27.5 %
82 Soft Coated Wheaten Terrier 27.5 %
83 Belgian Sheepdog 27.4 %
84 American Staffordshire Terrier 27.3 %
85 German Shorthaired Pointer 26.6 %
86 Boston Terrier 26.5 %
87 Rhodesian Ridgeback 26.4 %
88 Mastiff (English) 26.3 %
89 Portuguese Water Dog 26.3 %
90 Bouvier des Flandres 25.7 %
91 Pit Bull 25.2 %
92 Great Dane 24.9 %
93 Newfoundland 24.9 %
94 Schipperke 24.3 %
95 Alaskan Malamute 23.7 %
96 Akita 23.4 %
97 English Bulldog 23.0 %
98 Chinook 22.8 %
99 Bernese Mountain Dog 22.7 %
100 Chow Chow 21.7 %
101 Old English Sheepdog 21.1 %
102 Redbone Coonhound 20.9 %
103 Irish Water Spaniel 20.1 %
104 Scottish Terrier 19.7 %
105 Irish Wolfhound 17.6 %
106 German Wirehaired Pointer 17.5 %
107 Great Pyrenees 16.8 %
108 Gordon Setter 16.6 %
109 Bullmastiff 16.5 %
110 Irish Setter 16.4 %
111 Black and Tan Coonhound 14.3 %
112 Rottweiler 13.6 %
113 Siberian Husky 13.5 %
114 Nova Scotia Duck Tolling Retriever 12.9 %
115 Anatolian Shepherd 12.8 %
116 Dingo 12.2 %
117 Collie 11.4 %
118 Airedale Terrier 9.7 %
119 Pointer 9.7 %
120 Borzoi 8.4 %
121 Kuvasz 8.4 %
122 Eurasier 7.3 %
123 Ibizan Hound 7.2 %
124 Giant Schnauzer 0.0 %